Modern Times: The mane debate
Is the fear of short hair really a fear of women with power? Given the times, we're about to find out
By Katrina Onstad
Comments (7)
Last November, Winona Ryder showed up at the red-carpet premiere for the movie Milk self-referentially sporting the tousled early-’90s pixie hairstyle once known as “the Winona Ryder.” Thus followed a slew of style reporters making the official declaration, with the certainty of an army of Wiarton Willies, that short hair is back: Winona goes gamine again; Posh is cropped to new non-lengths; Rihanna swings her little acorn-cap triangle. As every journalist will tell you, three is a trend.
And yet, around the same time, short-hair anxiety began elbowing aside the fashion Nostradamuses. In The Guardian, a man wrote a much-blogged-about letter to an advice columnist asking, “Is it true that a woman with a short hairstyle is subconsciously indicating that she does not want sex? My wife had a drastic haircut four days before our wedding, and our sex life was a damp squib from the start.” If I were the Dear Abby in question, I would have answered with something like, “Dear Morony Moronison: Possibly, your wife may not want to have sex with someone who would ask as asinine a question as this, or use the phrase ‘damp squib.’’ The columnist was a little more delicate, but responded with the assertion that “reducing one’s attractiveness in a spouse’s eyes may well signal some desire to push them away.”
In other words, short hair is inherently unattractive, a sentiment echoed by a sex therapist named Aline Zoldbrod in the New York Daily News a few weeks later in a piece entitled “Edgy pixie haircuts are back, but do they kill your attraction?”
“If you cut your hair you might be making a statement that says, ‘I don’t want to be seen as a sex object,’ ” she told the reporter. Somehow, I can’t imagine any woman brushing her long hair in the morning and saying to herself, “Gee, I hope that today I get groped in an elevator, a guy at work will Twitter something pornographic about me and my character and ideas will run second to my hotness. Come on, long hair – let’s go be a sex object!”
It’s hardly news that hair is another battlefield in the gender wars. Women going short is often read as a rejection of conventional femininity, a rebellion against the long, blond, impossible Barbie-doll ideal (which may be why so many little girls, staring down the barrel of adolescence, take the nail scissors to Barbie’s head).
ChristinaS
great article
Long hair is certainly ingrained as a security blanket and short hair is seen as a risk, possibly as it's more challenging to look and feel feminine due to the ingrained culture from when we were young of "boys have short hair, girls have long hair". I've often thought that women with really beautiful faces like Halle Berry look best with short hair, as the face is shown off. I tried short hair one time but my significant other at that time preferred it long.
Posted Mon. 2 Feb., 2009 @ 1:26:30 PM
ElleBee
The long and short of it
When I was in my early 30's I had the misfortune of going to a male stylist who pegged me as too old for shoulder length hair and cut it into an unattractive, boxy thing that made me fade into the woodwork. Now more than a decade later I have longer, healthy hair that falls below my shoulders, mostly because it's easier to tie it up in a ponytail to tuck under my motorcycle helmet but also because it just makes me feel sexier and more youthful. If I thought for a second that it made me look like I was trying too hard to recapture my youth, I'd chop it off. But I'm not going to sacrifice the practicality of avoiding helmet head just because of someone else's ideal that short hair means power. Piffle!
Posted Tue. 3 Feb., 2009 @ 5:54:58 AM
Cari
Nature's Adornment
I think that combed-back short or tied-up long hair reflects a woman who is practical, with less time or money than a woman with stylish short or bouffant long hair. I keep my own hair cut evenly at shoulder length or longer so that I can fasten it up quickly to do a job, to cook, or simply to get through a hot flash.
Posted Wed. 18 Feb., 2009 @ 8:33:06 AM
Marlee D.
Short for Life
I read this article from the perspective of someone who has kept their hair short for nearly their entire life. While my life has not been particularily long (I am only seventeen), I can most definitely say that my hair length has affected who I have become. I never got a sense of empowerment or felt that I was better than others because I kept my hair cropped, but I definitely felt I was more free. I haven't had the safety blanket of my own hair since I was eight years old, leaving me with nothing to hide behind. I think that, in a way, being forced to stand out on my own has given me more confidence in my own abilities. I have nothing to hide behind. There's just me.
Posted Sat. 21 Feb., 2009 @ 2:25:08 PM
Trudy C
Other reasons for Short Hair
Hello Katrina,
You missed one important reason many of us wear short hair, and that is that it is the best style for our face shape and hair type. I have a narrow face and straight hair. A longer cut draws out my face and makes it look even narrower. I would love to wear it longer, but unless I perm it, which I would rather not, short hair suits my face the best - makes me longer younger :). PS my husband actually prefers me in short hair. Trudy
Posted Wed. 11 Mar., 2009 @ 4:26:50 PM
Leslie
For the love of short hair
I would just like to say that as a woman who LOVES short hair, I find the ideas of some non-modern minded females and sexist males appalling. The first time I went short, I was fourteen, my mom had just passed of cancer and I chopped my hair(which was bum-length)to create wigs for the cancer society. On a dare a few months later I shaved my head with a bic razor and loved it so much I did it two more times before my father got really upset and prohibited me from doing it again. I am now 25 and have had my hair at all different lengths but the look I like best is short. I think that as a society we are brainwashed into thinking that women must have long hair. The ones that don't are either proclaimed lesbians or are said to be trying to equal men. I say 'humbug' to that. Long live gutsy women with the courage and the fashion-forwardness to go ahead and go short!!
Posted Mon. 23 Mar., 2009 @ 1:34:35 PM
Lady
What do you think about this?
I 'had' a b/f who said that if a woman cuts her hair then she can't sit and whine if her man fools around on her. During this conversation I said that if I can't handle the work my long hair takes, shoulders get bad, health gets worse, that I may have to cut my hair. He shook his head back and forth and said, "women always let themselves go and cut their hair when they get older and then they cry the blues because us men go out and have an affair"
I said that love isn't based on the length of one's hair or their weight (as putting on weight with age had come up in this conversation too). He said that a woman should always look her best for her man. I said that a woman should always be loved for who she is no matter her hair length or weight. I said that when I'm at home I should be able to relax and if my hair and make up aren't done to perfection all the time it shouldn't make any difference. He persisted that that is why men have affairs and a woman should look her best for her man no matter what..
Which brought me to child birth and new babies and up all night. He said, 'well, I can see right after she has a baby and is in the hospital, but no matter what she should be looking good as her husband likes"
I was so livid with someone so shallow and...not even sure what word should be here for someone who could possibly think like this.
Be yourself and be loved for yourself...whether you want to have long, medium or short hair. Life is short. Enjoy it and don't try to live up to what someone should or thinks they should be thinking about you.
Chatboard (0)